Rent vs buy in Carmel, IN
A typical home in Carmel, Indiana costs $575,492, while typical rent is $1,864 /mo.
Renting costs $143k less over 7 years
With Carmel's typical rent and home value, the calculation includes 20% down at today's mortgage rate. No break-even point appears within 30 years.
The opinion is clearly labeled, and the math is shown. These figures are estimates, not quotes. The stamp updates whenever you change a number.
- Renting is ahead by
- $143k after 7 years
- Break-even point
- 30+ years owning never catches up sooner
- Full cost of owning
- $4,956 /mo year 1, against $1,864 rent
Change my numbers
The stamp draws on two figures: Carmel's typical rent and its typical home value. Your rent, price and time period may change the result.
Do your numbers differ from the city's?
Enter your rent, price and down payment. The stamp updates with those numbers.
In Carmel, is renting or buying cheaper?
Across 7 years, renting saves $143,449 after the money you receive from selling is included. In every year displayed, renting's net cost is lower than owning's, and owning still doesn't catch up within 30 years.
Rent option. Buy option. A year-by-year view of the net cost accumulated so far.
Carmel: average rent compared with mortgage payment
At Carmel's typical price, the full year 1 monthly costs include more than rent and mortgage. Here they are.
| Each month, year 1 | Amount | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | $1,864 | All of it, every month |
| Mortgage payment | $3,138 | $2,766 of it is interest in year 1 |
| Property tax | $398 | 0.83% of the value a year |
| Insurance | $138 | Census median for the city |
| Upkeep | $480 | 1% of the value a year |
| Owning, cash out | $4,153 | $372 of it builds equity |
| Lost return on the down payment | $935 | What the cash would earn each year at 8.3% |
| Buying costs, spread out | $240 | 3.5% of the price over 7 years |
| True cost of owning | $4,956 | Add the two lines above, then subtract the equity part from cash out. |
Numbers behind the Carmel verdict
- Typical home valueZillow ZHVI, September 2026
- $575,492
- Typical rentZillow ZORI, September 2026
- $1,864 /mo
- Down payment20% avoids private mortgage insurance, which the engine does not model
- 20%
- Mortgage rateFreddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (FRED MORTGAGE30US)
- 7.24%
- Home price growthFHFA house price index, Indiana, 1995 to 2025
- 3.7% a year
- Rent growthCPI rent of primary residence, yearly growth 2006 to 2026
- 3.5% a year
- Return on savings60% S&P 500 with dividends and 40% 10-year Treasuries, rebalanced yearly, 1928 to 2025
- 8.3% a year
- Property taxCensus ACS 2020-2024, Carmel
- 0.83% of value
- Home insuranceCensus ACS 2020-2024, Carmel
- $138 /mo
- MaintenanceFannie Mae, low end of 1% to 4%
- 1% of value a year
- Buying costsFreddie Mac, middle of 2% to 5%
- 3.5% of price
- Selling costsAgent commission plus closing costs
- 6% of price
What would reverse the Carmel result?
Each line shows the point where the 7-year verdict for Carmel changes, while everything else stays the same.
Renting is cheaper when
- Our calculation uses 3.7%, Indiana's long-run rate, for home prices growing more slowly than 6.6% a year.
- A mortgage rate over 2.73% remains above that level.
- A home like this has a monthly rent below $3,400, compared with the typical $1,864 here.
- If you move during the next 30 years, ownership still does not catch up under these figures.
When buying comes out ahead
- The yearly rate of home-price growth is above 6.6%.
- You secure a mortgage rate under 2.73%; today's rate is 7.24%.
- For the same home, monthly rent would exceed $3,400.
How Carmel compares with the other 812 cities
| Measure | Carmel | Median city |
|---|---|---|
| Typical home value | $575,492 | $422,451 |
| Typical rent | $1,864 /mo | $1,837 /mo |
| Price-to-rent ratio | 25.7 (#125 of 813) | 18.5 |
| Home prices, last 10 years | 6.2% a year | 6.2% a year |
| Rents, last 5 years | 4.5% a year | 4% a year |
| Property tax | 0.83% | 0.87% |
| Households that rent | 26% | 42% |
Sources: Zillow ZHVI and ZORI, Census ACS 2020-2024.
Other Indiana cities
- It's a toss-up. Renting leads by $2k in Indianapolis, IN.
- Rent wins by $20k in Fort Wayne, IN.
- Renting wins by $17k in Evansville, IN.
- Rent wins by $70k in Fishers, IN.
- Buying wins by $4k in South Bend, IN.
- Renting wins by $9k in Bloomington, IN.
- Buying wins by $37k in Hammond, IN.
- Rent. Noblesville, IN. Renting comes out ahead by $62k.
- Renting wins by $24k in Lafayette, IN.
- Rent. Greenwood, IN. Renting comes out ahead by $33k.
- Buying wins by $72k in Gary, IN.
- Buy. Muncie, IN. Buying comes out ahead by $8k.